MENOMONIE, Wis. — For more than a year, Menomonie has stood at the epicenter of a defining Midwest battle over whether small towns can protect their farmland, groundwater, and community character from hyperscale tech infrastructure. At its November 16, 2026 meeting, following guidance from Public Works Director David Schofield, the Menomonie City Council took the next major step in turning grassroots resistance into lasting local law—voting unanimously to refer two updated data center zoning measures, Proposed Ordinances 2027-01 and 2026-14, to the Plan Commission for formal review and a public hearing. The revised rules establish strict local safeguards—including a 30% open green space requirement, a 50% building coverage cap, and daylight-only construction hours—while ensuring that any future data center developer must still apply for a separate rezoning and public vote before building.

Guided by a briefing memorandum from Public Works Director David Schofield and special land-use counsel, the revised rules build what Mayor Matthew Crowe has described as a stronger defensive wall around the community—establishing strict environmental and operational safeguards while keeping the city on solid legal ground.

How We Got Here: A Timeline of Menomonie’s Stand

To understand why Monday night’s vote matters, it helps to look back at how far our community has come since The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger first began covering the fight:

  • August 2025 – The Spark: Balloonist LLC—a shell company representing Big Tech—moved to annex and rezone roughly 320 acres of agricultural land north of I-94 for a massive, $1.6 billion data center campus. Like countless rural communities, Menomonie faced a system where outdated zoning codes lumped power-hungry data centers into standard “warehousing” categories, allowing facilities to move forward with minimal oversight.
  • Late 2025 to April 2026 – Grassroots Mobilization & City Hall Turnover: Intense resident pushback forced tax incentive negotiations onto pause, led the council to adopt the initial Data Center Industrial (I-4) classification in January 2026 to strip data centers of “by-right” warehouse status, and ushered in a new administration in April 2026 committed to rewriting the rules.
  • Summer – October 2026 – Building a Stronger Wall: Following Mayor Crowe’s June 25 public update, the city introduced its comprehensive I-4 zoning draft on August 3 and refined it through multiple versions. As chronicled in our previous reporting—including Decibels, Water, and Farmland: Menomonie’s Multi-Front Stand Against Balloonist LLC and How a Multi-Million-Dollar Proxy War is Fracturing Menomonie—debates at City Hall grew heated as multiple fronts began demanding more out of fear and a misunderstanding of the I-4 ordinance’s true legal purpose, pushing extreme changes that risked undermining the city’s legal strategy.

Why Are There Two Separate Ordinances?

Residents following Monday night’s agenda noticed the Council voted on two distinct measures rather than one. Because municipal zoning codes are organized into separate chapters, regulating data centers requires a two-part legal shield—both creating a strict new set of rules and closing an existing loophole in the older code:

  • Proposed Ordinance 2027-01 – Builds the New Rules (I-4 District): Amends Title 10, Chapter 23 (Data Center Industrial District) to write the dedicated rulebook for any future data center, setting strict standards for height, green space, lot coverage, construction hours, water, power, noise, and light.
  • Proposed Ordinance 2026-14 – Closes the Old Loophole (I-3 District): Amends Title 10, Chapter 16 (General Industrial District) to explicitly remove data centers from general industrial and warehousing uses.

If the city only updated the I-4 rules (2027-01) without changing the I-3 rules (2026-14), a developer could argue that their facility qualifies as a standard warehouse on existing I-3 industrial land and bypass the stricter I-4 requirements altogether. Passing both ensures data centers are blocked from general industrial zones and can only be considered if a developer applies for the strict I-4 classification and wins a public vote.

Why Public Works Director David Schofield Rejected a 1,000-Square-Foot Cap

During recent public hearings and online campaigns, some local activists lobbied for an arbitrary flat square-footage limit—suggesting caps as small as 1,000 square feet—to effectively ban data centers altogether. In his guidance to the Council, Public Works Director David Schofield recommended against using a 1,000-square-foot limit, explaining why proportional density rules provide far stronger, lasting protection:

  • Preventing Multi-Building Loopholes: A flat per-building square-footage cap can easily be circumvented if a developer simply constructs multiple smaller buildings across a parcel. Percentage-based lot coverage caps regulate the entire site as a whole.
  • Avoiding “Arbitrary & Capricious” Court Challenges: Under Wisconsin zoning law, picking an arbitrary figure like 1,000 square feet without an engineering or public-health rationale invites immediate legal challenges. Proportional limits on lot coverage, setbacks, and height are directly tied to measurable municipal planning standards—such as stormwater runoff, groundwater recharge, and fire-department access—making them far easier to defend in court.
  • Dodging the “Regulatory Taking” Trap: Setting a cap so small that no viable industrial facility could ever operate exposes Menomonie taxpayers to costly Fifth Amendment and Wisconsin inverse-condemnation (“regulatory taking”) lawsuits. As we noted in our November 12 update, if a judge strikes down an overreaching ordinance as an unconstitutional ban disguised as zoning, the entire I-4 framework collapses—leaving Menomonie with zero protections.

What the November 16 Updates Do

Instead of taking that legal gamble, Schofield and outside land-use attorneys refined the text to push municipal authority to its highest legally defensible limit. The updated package sent to the Plan Commission includes:

  • Mandatory Open Green Space (30%): Under Proposed Ordinance 2027-01 (Title 10, Chapter 23), total site coverage—including buildings and paved parking—cannot exceed 70%, legally mandating that at least 30% of any I-4 property remains dedicated green space, landscaping, or agricultural land (excluding rooftop plantings).
  • Building Coverage & Height Limits: Individual building footprints are capped at 50% of a lot, paired with strict 45-foot (three-story) height limits and wide property setbacks.
  • Daylight-Only Construction: Allowable construction hours are tightened from 6:00 a.m.–9:00 p.m. down to 7:00 a.m.–7:00 p.m. to protect nearby homes from early-morning and late-evening noise.
  • Resource & Loophole Protections: The framework maintains aggressive limits on water consumption, electricity demand, noise, and light pollution, while Proposed Ordinance 2026-14 (Title 10, Chapter 16) formally removes data centers from General Industrial (I-3) uses so no developer can bypass the I-4 rules.

Remember: Zero Acres Are Zoned I-4

As Schofield emphasized in his memo to the Mayor and City Council, no land in Menomonie is currently zoned I-4—including the paused Balloonist LLC site.

Passing these ordinances puts the protective rulebook in place, but it does not greenlight a single shovel of dirt. As Mayor Crowe explained in his statement featured in our November 14 coverage, “We have built the wall, we are building a stronger wall, if anyone applies for the I-4 zone, this gives the council and mayor the power to stand on the wall and vote no to any data center development.”

What Happens Next

Both ordinances now move to the Menomonie Plan Commission for technical review and a public hearing before returning to the City Council for final adoption. You can inspect the full November 16 meeting packet and Schofield’s memo on the City of Menomonie Agenda Center.

Menomonie proved that when neighbors show up and demand smart, enforceable zoning, a small town can stand its ground against Big Tech. Keep watching the city calendar—and get ready to make your voice heard at the Plan Commission hearing.

“We have a strong, smart ordinance sitting right in front of us. As a neighbor who loves living here, I’m asking you to protect Menomonie, steer clear of legal traps, and pass the final draft of the I-4 Ordinance tonight, and forward it on to the Planning Commission for final adoption.” ~Jan O’Neill, Menomonie City Resident


Red Cedar Watershed Ledger Authors

Rachel Tilseth is a Menomonie, Wisconsin-based environmental writer, filmmaker, and owner of Wolves of Douglas County WI Films & Media. Lead writer at The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger. Her work explores the intricate relationships between humans, wildlife, and local ecosystems.

Jan O’Neill- editor at large. Jan edits the blog for grammatical accuracy and contributes story ideas.

Given Jan’s extensive 45-year nursing background, protecting the health and well-being of the Menomonie area has been her life’s work. With deep local roots in the Red Cedar River Watershed, she views environmental conservation as a natural extension of public health. Jan is dedicated to halting the proposed mega data center to preserve the community’s natural resources, advocating instead for sustainable, community-driven economic development that protects the long-term quality of our watershed.

Danny Akenson

Danny Akenson is a community organizer for GROWW (Grassroots Organizing Western Wisconsin) and a UW-River Falls graduate. Having grown up in a small town in western Wisconsin, he has seen first-hand the impacts of rural areas losing opportunities all while our environment pays the price. For four years, he has organized with the hope that rural Wisconsin can be a land of opportunity again.


The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger is based in Menomonie, Wisconsin, in the historic Red Cedar Basin.

Discover how our local economy can thrive without leaving the planet behind. We cover news and stories on sustainable economic development, highlighting initiatives that boost community prosperity, foster equity, and protect our local ecosystems.

The Mission

The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger (RCWL) empowers individuals to actively support one another by fostering community-led citizen groups dedicated to creating safer, healthier local environments. Operating outside traditional non-profits, the RCWL focuses on educating the public about environmental sustainability and ecological economics. Through this shared knowledge, community members learn practical ways to care for both their neighbors and their surroundings, ultimately promoting a balanced, harmonious relationship with nature.

The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger, Menomonie, WI

Wolves of Douglas CO WI Films & Media, LLC

https://wolvesofdouglascountywisconsin.com


Thank you for your donation to the Red Cedar Watershed Ledger!


Discover more from The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Rachel Tilseth's avatar

By Rachel Tilseth

I am a Menomonie, Wisconsin-based environmental writer, filmmaker, and owner of Wolves of Douglas County WI Films & Media. My work explores the relationships between humans, wildlife, and local ecosystems, focusing on threats to vulnerable habitats. Through independent, grassroots media, I advocate for sustainable coexistence with apex predators and educate the public on ecological economics. My award-winning short film, People & Wolves: A Story of Coexistence, won Best Documentary Short at the Red Cedar Film Festival and features insights from Dr. Jane Goodall, Ojibwa tribal members, hunters, and biologists.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from The Red Cedar Watershed Ledger

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading